glibc/math
Adhemerval Zanella 3e8814903c math: Refactor how to use libm-test-ulps
The current approach tracks math maximum supported errors by explicitly
setting them per function and architecture. On newer implementations or
new compiler versions, the file is updated with newer values if it
shows higher results. The idea is to track the maximum known error, to
update the manual with the obtained values.

The constant libm-test-ulps shows little value, where it is usually a
mechanical change done by the maintainer, for past releases it is
usually ignored whether the ulp change resulted from a compiler
regression, and the math tests already have a maximum ulp error that
triggers a regression.

It was shown by a recent update after the new acosf [1] implementation
that is correctly rounded, where the libm-test-ulps was indeed from a
compiler issue.

This patch removes all arch-specific libm-test-ulps, adds system generic
libm-test-ulps where applicable, and changes its semantics. The generic
files now track specific implementation constraints, like if it is
expected to be correctly rounded, or if the system-specific has
different error expectations.

Now multiple libm-test-ulps can be defined, and system-specific
overrides generic implementation.  This is for the case where
arch-specific implementation might show worse precision than generic
implementation, for instance, the cbrtf on i686.

Regressions are only reported if the implementation shows larger errors
than 9 ulps (13 for IBM long double) unless it is overridden by
libm-test-ulps and the maximum error is not printed at the end of tests.
The regen-ulps rule is also removed since it does not make sense to
update the libm-test-ulps automatically.

The manual error table is also removed, Paul Zimmermann and others have
been tracking libm precision with a more comprehensive analysis for some
releases; so link to his work instead.

[1] https://sourceware.org/git/?p=glibc.git;a=commit;h=9cc9f8e11e8fb8f54f1e84d9f024917634a78201
2025-03-12 13:40:07 -03:00
..
bits
finclude
machine
Makefile math: Refactor how to use libm-test-ulps 2025-03-12 13:40:07 -03:00
README.libm-test math: Refactor how to use libm-test-ulps 2025-03-12 13:40:07 -03:00
Versions
atest-exp.c
atest-exp2.c
atest-sincos.c
auto-libm-test-in
auto-libm-test-out-acos
auto-libm-test-out-acosh
auto-libm-test-out-acospi
auto-libm-test-out-asin
auto-libm-test-out-asinh
auto-libm-test-out-asinpi
auto-libm-test-out-atan
auto-libm-test-out-atan2
auto-libm-test-out-atan2pi
auto-libm-test-out-atanh
auto-libm-test-out-atanpi
auto-libm-test-out-cabs
auto-libm-test-out-cacos
auto-libm-test-out-cacosh
auto-libm-test-out-carg
auto-libm-test-out-casin
auto-libm-test-out-casinh
auto-libm-test-out-catan
auto-libm-test-out-catanh
auto-libm-test-out-cbrt
auto-libm-test-out-ccos
auto-libm-test-out-ccosh
auto-libm-test-out-cexp
auto-libm-test-out-clog
auto-libm-test-out-clog10
auto-libm-test-out-cos
auto-libm-test-out-cosh
auto-libm-test-out-cospi
auto-libm-test-out-cpow
auto-libm-test-out-csin
auto-libm-test-out-csinh
auto-libm-test-out-csqrt
auto-libm-test-out-ctan
auto-libm-test-out-ctanh
auto-libm-test-out-erf
auto-libm-test-out-erfc
auto-libm-test-out-exp
auto-libm-test-out-exp2
auto-libm-test-out-exp2m1
auto-libm-test-out-exp10
auto-libm-test-out-exp10m1
auto-libm-test-out-expm1
auto-libm-test-out-fma
auto-libm-test-out-hypot
auto-libm-test-out-j0
auto-libm-test-out-j1
auto-libm-test-out-jn
auto-libm-test-out-lgamma
auto-libm-test-out-log
auto-libm-test-out-log1p
auto-libm-test-out-log2
auto-libm-test-out-log2p1
auto-libm-test-out-log10
auto-libm-test-out-log10p1
auto-libm-test-out-narrow-add
auto-libm-test-out-narrow-div
auto-libm-test-out-narrow-fma
auto-libm-test-out-narrow-mul
auto-libm-test-out-narrow-sqrt
auto-libm-test-out-narrow-sub
auto-libm-test-out-pow
auto-libm-test-out-rsqrt
auto-libm-test-out-sin
auto-libm-test-out-sincos
auto-libm-test-out-sinh
auto-libm-test-out-sinpi
auto-libm-test-out-sqrt
auto-libm-test-out-tan
auto-libm-test-out-tanh
auto-libm-test-out-tanpi
auto-libm-test-out-tgamma
auto-libm-test-out-y0
auto-libm-test-out-y1
auto-libm-test-out-yn
basic-test.c
bug-nextafter.c
bug-nexttoward.c
bug-tgmath1.c
cabs_template.c
carg_template.c
cimag_template.c
complex.h
conj_template.c
creal_template.c
divtc3.c
e_exp2_template.c
e_scalb_template.c
fclrexcpt.c
fedisblxcpt.c
feenablxcpt.c
fegetenv.c
fegetexcept.c
fegetmode.c
fegetround.c
feholdexcpt.c
fenv.h
fesetenv.c
fesetexcept.c
fesetmode.c
fesetround.c
fetestexceptflag.c
feupdateenv.c
fgetexcptflg.c
fpu_control.c
fraiseexcpt.c
fromfp.h
fsetexcptflg.c
ftestexcept.c
gen-auto-libm-tests.c
gen-fromfp-tests-inputs
gen-fromfp-tests.py
gen-libm-test.py math: Refactor how to use libm-test-ulps 2025-03-12 13:40:07 -03:00
gen-tgmath-tests.py
k_casinh_template.c
k_sincosl.c
lgamma-compat.h
libm-test-acos.inc
libm-test-acosh.inc
libm-test-acospi.inc
libm-test-asin.inc
libm-test-asinh.inc
libm-test-asinpi.inc
libm-test-atan.inc
libm-test-atan2.inc
libm-test-atan2pi.inc
libm-test-atanh.inc
libm-test-atanpi.inc
libm-test-cabs.inc
libm-test-cacos.inc
libm-test-cacosh.inc
libm-test-canonicalize.inc
libm-test-carg.inc
libm-test-casin.inc
libm-test-casinh.inc
libm-test-catan.inc
libm-test-catanh.inc
libm-test-cbrt.inc
libm-test-ccos.inc
libm-test-ccosh.inc
libm-test-ceil.inc
libm-test-cexp.inc
libm-test-cimag.inc
libm-test-clog.inc
libm-test-clog10.inc
libm-test-compat_totalorder.inc
libm-test-compat_totalordermag.inc
libm-test-conj.inc
libm-test-copysign.inc
libm-test-cos.inc
libm-test-cosh.inc
libm-test-cospi.inc
libm-test-cpow.inc
libm-test-cproj.inc
libm-test-creal.inc
libm-test-csin.inc
libm-test-csinh.inc
libm-test-csqrt.inc
libm-test-ctan.inc
libm-test-ctanh.inc
libm-test-driver.c
libm-test-erf.inc
libm-test-erfc.inc
libm-test-exp.inc
libm-test-exp2.inc
libm-test-exp2m1.inc
libm-test-exp10.inc
libm-test-exp10m1.inc
libm-test-expm1.inc
libm-test-fabs.inc
libm-test-fdim.inc
libm-test-floor.inc
libm-test-fma.inc
libm-test-fmax.inc
libm-test-fmaximum.inc
libm-test-fmaximum_mag.inc
libm-test-fmaximum_mag_num.inc
libm-test-fmaximum_num.inc
libm-test-fmaxmag.inc
libm-test-fmin.inc
libm-test-fminimum.inc
libm-test-fminimum_mag.inc
libm-test-fminimum_mag_num.inc
libm-test-fminimum_num.inc
libm-test-fminmag.inc
libm-test-fmod.inc
libm-test-fpclassify.inc
libm-test-frexp.inc
libm-test-fromfp.inc
libm-test-fromfpx.inc
libm-test-getpayload.inc
libm-test-hypot.inc
libm-test-ilogb.inc
libm-test-iscanonical.inc
libm-test-iseqsig.inc
libm-test-isfinite.inc
libm-test-isgreater.inc
libm-test-isgreaterequal.inc
libm-test-isinf.inc
libm-test-isless.inc
libm-test-islessequal.inc
libm-test-islessgreater.inc
libm-test-isnan.inc
libm-test-isnormal.inc
libm-test-issignaling.inc
libm-test-issubnormal.inc
libm-test-isunordered.inc
libm-test-iszero.inc
libm-test-j0.inc
libm-test-j1.inc
libm-test-jn.inc
libm-test-lgamma.inc
libm-test-llogb.inc
libm-test-llrint.inc
libm-test-llround.inc
libm-test-log.inc
libm-test-log1p.inc
libm-test-log2.inc
libm-test-log2p1.inc
libm-test-log10.inc
libm-test-log10p1.inc
libm-test-logb.inc
libm-test-lrint.inc
libm-test-lround.inc
libm-test-modf.inc
libm-test-narrow-add.inc
libm-test-narrow-div.inc
libm-test-narrow-fma.inc
libm-test-narrow-mul.inc
libm-test-narrow-sqrt.inc
libm-test-narrow-sub.inc
libm-test-nearbyint.inc
libm-test-nextafter.inc
libm-test-nextdown.inc
libm-test-nexttoward.inc
libm-test-nextup.inc
libm-test-pow.inc
libm-test-remainder.inc
libm-test-remquo.inc
libm-test-rint.inc
libm-test-round.inc
libm-test-roundeven.inc
libm-test-rsqrt.inc
libm-test-scalb.inc
libm-test-scalbln.inc
libm-test-scalbn.inc
libm-test-setpayload.inc
libm-test-setpayloadsig.inc
libm-test-signbit.inc
libm-test-significand.inc
libm-test-sin.inc
libm-test-sincos.inc
libm-test-sinh.inc
libm-test-sinpi.inc
libm-test-sqrt.inc
libm-test-support.c math: Refactor how to use libm-test-ulps 2025-03-12 13:40:07 -03:00
libm-test-support.h
libm-test-tan.inc
libm-test-tanh.inc
libm-test-tanpi.inc
libm-test-tgamma.inc
libm-test-totalorder.inc
libm-test-totalordermag.inc
libm-test-trunc.inc
libm-test-ufromfp.inc
libm-test-ufromfpx.inc
libm-test-y0.inc
libm-test-y1.inc
libm-test-yn.inc
math-narrow.h
math-svid-compat.h
math-underflow.h
math.h
mul_split.h
mul_splitl.h
multc3.c
s_acospi_template.c
s_asinpi_template.c
s_atan2pi_template.c
s_atanpi_template.c
s_cacos_template.c
s_cacosh_template.c
s_canonicalize_template.c
s_casin_template.c
s_casinh_template.c
s_catan_template.c
s_catanh_template.c
s_ccos_template.c
s_ccosh_template.c
s_cexp_template.c
s_clog10_template.c
s_clog_template.c
s_cospi_template.c
s_cpow_template.c
s_cproj_template.c
s_csin_template.c
s_csinh_template.c
s_csqrt_template.c
s_ctan_template.c
s_ctanh_template.c
s_exp2m1_template.c
s_exp10m1_template.c
s_fdim_template.c
s_fmax_template.c
s_fmaximum_mag_num_template.c
s_fmaximum_mag_template.c
s_fmaximum_num_template.c
s_fmaximum_template.c
s_fmaxmag_template.c
s_fmin_template.c
s_fminimum_mag_num_template.c
s_fminimum_mag_template.c
s_fminimum_num_template.c
s_fminimum_template.c
s_fminmag_template.c
s_iscanonicall.c
s_iseqsig_template.c
s_ldexp_template.c
s_log2p1_template.c
s_log10p1_template.c
s_nan_template.c
s_nextafter.c
s_nextdown_template.c
s_nexttowardf.c
s_nexttowardl.c
s_rsqrt_template.c
s_significand_template.c
s_sinpi_template.c
s_tanpi_template.c
setfpucw.c
t_sincosl.c
test-arg-double.h
test-arg-float32x.h
test-arg-float64.h
test-arg-float64x.h
test-arg-float128.h
test-arg-ldouble.h
test-ceil-except-2.c
test-double-static.h
test-double-vlen2.h
test-double-vlen4.h
test-double-vlen8.h
test-double.h
test-fe-snans-always-signal.c
test-femode-traps.c
test-femode.c
test-fenv-clear-main.c
test-fenv-clear.c
test-fenv-preserve.c
test-fenv-return.c
test-fenv-tls.c
test-fenv.c
test-fesetexcept-traps.c
test-fesetexcept.c
test-fetestexceptflag.c
test-fexcept-traps.c
test-fexcept.c
test-float-static.h
test-float-vlen4.h
test-float-vlen8.h
test-float-vlen16.h
test-float.h
test-float32-static.h
test-float32.h
test-float32x-static.h
test-float32x.h
test-float64-static.h
test-float64.h
test-float64x-static.h
test-float64x.h
test-float128-static.h
test-float128.h
test-floor-except-2.c
test-flt-eval-method.c
test-fp-ilogb-constants.c
test-fp-llogb-constants.c
test-fpucw-ieee-static.c
test-fpucw-ieee.c
test-fpucw-static.c
test-fpucw.c
test-ibm128-static.h
test-ibm128.h
test-iseqsig-excess-precision.c
test-iszero-excess-precision.c
test-ldouble-static.h
test-ldouble.h
test-math-cxx11.cc
test-math-errno.h
test-math-exceptions.h
test-math-floatn.h
test-math-iscanonical.cc
test-math-iseqsig.cc
test-math-isinff.cc
test-math-issignaling.cc
test-math-iszero.cc
test-math-narrow.h
test-math-scalar.h
test-math-vector.h
test-matherr-2.c
test-matherr-3.c
test-matherr.c
test-misc.c
test-nan-const.c
test-nan-overflow.c
test-nan-payload.c
test-narrow-macros.c
test-nearbyint-except-2.c
test-nearbyint-except.c
test-powl.c
test-signgam-main.c
test-signgam-uchar-init-static.c
test-signgam-uchar-init.c
test-signgam-uchar-static.c
test-signgam-uchar.c
test-signgam-uint-init-static.c
test-signgam-uint-init.c
test-signgam-uint-static.c
test-signgam-uint.c
test-signgam-ullong-init-static.c
test-signgam-ullong-init.c
test-signgam-ullong-static.c
test-signgam-ullong.c
test-snan.c
test-tgmath-int.c
test-tgmath-ret.c
test-tgmath.c
test-tgmath2.c
test-trunc-except-2.c
tgmath.h
tst-CMPLX.c
tst-CMPLX2.c
tst-definitions.c
w_acos_compat.c
w_acos_template.c
w_acosf_compat.c
w_acosh_compat.c
w_acosh_template.c
w_acoshf_compat.c
w_acoshl_compat.c
w_acosl_compat.c
w_asin_compat.c
w_asin_template.c
w_asinf_compat.c
w_asinl_compat.c
w_atan2_compat.c
w_atan2_template.c
w_atan2f_compat.c
w_atan2l_compat.c
w_atanh_compat.c
w_atanh_template.c
w_atanhf_compat.c
w_atanhl_compat.c
w_cosh_compat.c
w_cosh_template.c
w_coshf_compat.c
w_coshl_compat.c
w_exp.c
w_exp2.c
w_exp2_compat.c
w_exp2_template.c
w_exp2f.c
w_exp2f_compat.c
w_exp2l_compat.c
w_exp10_compat.c
w_exp10_template.c
w_exp10f.c
w_exp10f_compat.c
w_exp10l_compat.c
w_exp_compat.c
w_exp_template.c
w_expf.c
w_expf_compat.c
w_expl_compat.c
w_fmod_compat.c
w_fmod_template.c
w_fmodf_compat.c
w_fmodl_compat.c
w_hypot.c
w_hypot_compat.c
w_hypot_template.c
w_hypotf.c
w_hypotf_compat.c
w_hypotl_compat.c
w_ilogb_template.c
w_j0_compat.c
w_j0_template.c
w_j0f_compat.c
w_j0l_compat.c
w_j1_compat.c
w_j1_template.c
w_j1f_compat.c
w_j1l_compat.c
w_jn_compat.c
w_jn_template.c
w_jnf_compat.c
w_jnl_compat.c
w_lgamma.c
w_lgamma_compat.c
w_lgamma_compat2.c
w_lgamma_compatf.c
w_lgamma_compatl.c
w_lgamma_main.c
w_lgamma_r_compat.c
w_lgamma_r_template.c
w_lgamma_template.c
w_lgammaf.c
w_lgammaf_compat2.c
w_lgammaf_main.c
w_lgammaf_r_compat.c
w_lgammal.c
w_lgammal_compat2.c
w_lgammal_main.c
w_lgammal_r_compat.c
w_llogb_template.c
w_log.c
w_log1p_template.c
w_log2.c
w_log2_compat.c
w_log2_template.c
w_log2f.c
w_log2f_compat.c
w_log2l_compat.c
w_log10_compat.c
w_log10_template.c
w_log10f_compat.c
w_log10l_compat.c
w_log_compat.c
w_log_template.c
w_logf.c
w_logf_compat.c
w_logl_compat.c
w_pow.c
w_pow_compat.c
w_pow_template.c
w_powf.c
w_powf_compat.c
w_powl_compat.c
w_remainder.c
w_remainder_compat.c
w_remainder_template.c
w_remainderf.c
w_remainderf_compat.c
w_remainderl.c
w_remainderl_compat.c
w_scalb_compat.c
w_scalb_template.c
w_scalbf_compat.c
w_scalbl_compat.c
w_scalbln_template.c
w_sinh_compat.c
w_sinh_template.c
w_sinhf_compat.c
w_sinhl_compat.c
w_sqrt_compat.c
w_sqrt_template.c
w_sqrtf_compat.c
w_sqrtl_compat.c
w_tgamma_compat.c
w_tgamma_template.c
w_tgammaf_compat.c
w_tgammal_compat.c

README.libm-test

README for libm-test math test suite
====================================

The libm-test math test suite tests a number of function points of
math functions in the GNU C library.  The following sections contain a
brief overview.  Please note that the test drivers and the Python
script "gen-libm-test.py" have some options.  A full list of options
is available with --help (for the test drivers) and -h for
"gen-libm-test.py".


What is tested?
===============
The tests just evaluate the functions at specified points and compare
the results with precomputed values and the requirements of the ISO
C99 standard.

Besides testing the special values mandated by IEEE 754 (infinities,
NaNs and minus zero), some more or less random values are tested.

Files that are part of libm-test
================================

The main files are "libm-test-<func>.inc".  They are independent of
the target platform and the specific real floating type and format and
contain placeholder test "templates" for math functions defined in
libm.  These files, along with generated files named
"auto-libm-test-out-<func>", are preprocessed by the Python script
"gen-libm-test.py" to expand the templates and produce a set of test
cases for each math function that are specific to the target platform
but still independent of the real floating type.  The results of the
processing are "libm-test-<func>.c" and a file "libm-test-ulps.h" with
specific math results that can be either generic for the floating
type or platform specific.

The test drivers "test-double-<func>.c", "test-float-<func>.c", and
"test-ldouble-<func>.c", generated by the Makefile, test the normal
double, float and long double implementation of libm.  Each driver
selects the desired real floating type to exercise the math functions
to test with (float, double, or long double) by defining a small set
of macros just before including the generic "libm-test.c" file. Each
driver is compiled into a single executable test program with the
corresponding name.

The math tests do not report up to 9 Units of Least Precision (ULP)
(13 for IBM long double format) difference between the obtained
result and the expected one as a regression.  The "gen-libm-test.py"
script looks for files named "libm-test-ulps" in the sysdep directories
to generate the "libm-test-ulps.h" file.

The "auto-libm-test-out-<func>" files contain sets of test cases to
exercise, the conditions under which to exercise each, and the
expected results.  The files are generated by the
"gen-auto-libm-tests" program from the "auto-libm-test-in" file.  See
the comments in gen-auto-libm-tests.c for details about the content
and format of the -in and -out files.

How can I use "libm-test-ulps"?
====================================

A "libm-test-ulps" is required only to test for extra constraints in
the math tests.  The file contains lines for maximal errors of single
functions, like:

Function "yn":
float: 2
double: 6

It means that if the "yn" shows error larger than 2 ULP for float
or 6 ULP for double, the related test for "symbol" will fail.  It can
be useful to check for correctly rounded implementation, where the
expected ULP is 0.

The function is tested with default FE_TONEAREST rounding mode.  To
check with a different one, the function definition name should be
prepended with an underline plus the rounding mode 'downward' (FE_DOWNWARD),
'towardzero' (FE_TOWARDZERO), or 'upward' (FE_UPWARD).  For instance,

Function "yn_downward":
float: 3
double: 7

It means that 'yn' will be checked with FE_DOWNWARD rounding mode
and any error larger than 3 ULPs for float or 7 ULPs for double will be
reported as a regression.

The keywords are float, double, ldouble, and float128.

Also, multiple "libm-test-ulps" can be added, "gen-libm-test.py" will
merge the input in only one table.

Note that the test drivers have an option "-u" to output an unsorted
list of all epsilons that the functions have.  The output can be read
in directly but it's better to pretty print it first.
"gen-libm-test.py" has an option to generate a pretty-printed and
sorted new ULPs file from the output of the test drivers.


Adding tests to libm-test-<func>.inc
====================================

The tests are evaluated by a set of special test macros.  The macros
start with "TEST_" followed by a specification the input values, an
underscore and a specification of the output values.  As an example,
the test macro for a function with input of type FLOAT (FLOAT is
either float, double, long double) and output of type FLOAT is
"TEST_f_f".  The macro's parameter are the name of the function, the
input parameter, output parameter and optionally one exception
parameter.

The accepted parameter types are:
- "f" for FLOAT
- "j" for long double.
- "a" for ARG_FLOAT, the argument type for narrowing functions.
- "b" for boolean - just tests if the output parameter evaluates to 0
  or 1 (only for output).
- "c" for complex.  This parameter needs two values, first the real,
  then the imaginary part.
- "i" for int.
- "l" for long int.
- "L" for long long int.
- "u" for unsigned int.
- "M" for intmax_t.
- "U" for uintmax_t.
- "p" for an argument (described in the previous character) passed
  through a pointer rather than directly.
- "F" for the address of a FLOAT (only as input parameter)
- "I" for the address of an int (only as input parameter)
- "1" for an additional output (either output through a pointer passed
  as an argument, or to a global variable such as signgam).

How to read the test output
===========================

Running each test on its own at the default level of verbosity will
print on stdout a line describing the implementation of math functions
exercised by the test (float, double, or long double).  This is then
followed by the details of test failures (if any).  The output concludes
by a summary listing the number of test cases exercised and the number
of test failures uncovered.

For each test failure (and for each test case at higher levels of
verbosity), the output contains the name of the function under test
and its arguments or conditions that triggered the failure.  Note
that the name of the function in the output need not correspond
exactly to the name of the math function actually invoked. For example,
the output will refer to the "acos" function even if the actual function
under test is acosf (for the float version) or acosl (for the long
double version).  Also note that the function arguments may be shown
in either the decimal or the  hexadecimal floating point format which
may or may not correspond to the format used in the auto-libm-test-in
file. Besides the name of the function, for each test failure the
output contains the actual and expected results and the difference
between the two, printed in both the decimal and hexadecimal
floating point format, and the ULP and maximum ULP for the test
case.